The Wall Street Journal has reviewed three of the most popular sites.
Google Health doesn't have many tools of its own to allow users to evaluate their health. Instead, it focuses on sharing your data with online applications that do such tasks, like the My Diabetes Health Assessment website, which evaluates users' risk of diabetes based on data from their health records.The Journal's assessment:
Microsoft HealthVault, too, has a limited number of self-evaluation tools but connects to a wide variety of helpful services that can extract data from or import data to your profile.
You can accesss WebMD's Health Manager in two main ways: through its public site, WebMD.com, or through the sites of insurance companies and employers that are WebMD customers.
In the end, we found that each PHR offers a remarkable value for a free application, but none of the three emerged as a clear winner.
Microsoft HealthVault gets high marks for portability, but it has no features for printing. WebMD Health Manager has all of its health evaluation features built in, so you don't have to connect to external applications, but it lacks the ability to export information in some key industry formats. So does Google Health (it says it may add this later), but it does export data to online health applications.
One way to choose among the PHRs is by the applications that link to them. If you want to import data from LifeScan Inc.'s OneTouch glucose monitor into your PHR, for example, currently only HealthVault does that (Google may add this).
On the other hand, if your insurance company (yours or your employer's) is a WebMD customer, you may want to use Health Manager for its easy importing of all the health data your insurance company already has on you.
Also posted on my technology blog, My Skunkworks
No comments:
Post a Comment